The Devaluation of Culture

The Devaluation of Culture

(No, not the midterms. Ancient Greek Theatre.)

By Michael Dorf | Oct 25, 2026

I’ve been producing shows for over 40 years, on stages all over the world. City Winery alone now has 15 stages in the U.S., all East of the Mississippi, with shows every night. We’re on pace for about 6,500 shows this year. So I was humbled the other day, standing in my second Greek theatre that I visited in Sicily, to learn that the ancient Greeks had hundreds of venues across the Mediterranean putting on tragedy, comedy, satyr plays, and political satire.

These venues were built for theatre. They had real backstage areas for the actors, space under the stage for equipment and props, and even water running from stone aqueducts into pools and cisterns for the audience and the performers. Estimates put the surviving remains at somewhere between 200 and 350 theaters, from Greece to Turkey, Southern Italy, and the Black Sea. Live Nation would have had some serious competition in the 5th century BCE. Yes, 2,500 years ago, free water and no merch.

If I say “the Greek Theatre” to most of my staff, they’ll picture the roughly 6,000-seat amphitheater in LA’s Griffith Park, or the terrific Greek Theatre in Berkeley, CA. The Grateful Dead played the Berkeley Greek 29 times in their daze, and the iconic moments from those shows got passed around a million times on traded tapes.

What I found disturbing was learning that many of these beautiful Greek theatres were later turned into Roman arenas, rebuilt for the newer and more popular art form: state-sponsored gladiator fights and wild-beast hunts. I enjoyed the Russell Crowe movie, but that shit was brutal. I understand the appetite for blood, but it wrecked the theatre business. It’s not a perfect contemporary analogy, but football is a lot more popular than opera, modern dance or most theater. What is it about physical violence that grabs us more than a good comedy, or a harpsichord and a glass of wine?

Those damn Romans. Their conquests across three continents didn’t just hurt theatre. (I’m spelling it both ways). They changed the course of world history and religion in the Middle East. From the Crucifixion of Jesus to the destruction of the Second Temple in Jerusalem and the subsequent spread of the Jewish Diaspora: holy moly, did they shape our world. And where did the great Greek playwrights go, Sophocles, Aeschylus, and Euripides? (I had to look those names up. I don’t know anything about this stuff.)

After Rome fell, the big venue complexes gave way to small local scenes. In the Middle Ages, troubadours, minstrels, and acrobats toured taverns and marketplaces. The Church suppressed secular theatre until around the 16th century, when European cities grew and purpose-built public playhouses appeared, like Shakespeare’s Globe. Then came the cabinets of curiosities and wonder shows, circuses, which led to P.T. Barnum. Then electricity and technology changed everything, and boom, we get to CBGB’s on the Bowery. That’s the history of live entertainment in one paragraph

Here’s my real point. Civilization went from sophisticated live art to men killing each other for an audience, and in some ways we never fully recovered. Look at what fills our stadiums, our screens, and our politics. The appetite hasn’t changed much in 2,000 years. The ruins just sit there with the arena carved into the theatre, showing exactly what we traded away and how easily we did it. Sitting on those stone seats, I thought about our 6,500 shows this year. A few hundred people, a glass of wine, someone on stage worth listening to. It’s a small, unglamorous rebellion against the arena, but I’ll take it.

Michael Dorf is the founder of City Winery and The Knitting Factory. He writes regularly about live music, venue building, and the fight to keep independent culture alive.

Read more from Michael Dorf on Substack

Back to blog